Manual or Electric Wheelchair: Which One Should You Roll With?
June 17, 2023

Manual or Electric Wheelchair: Which One Should You Roll With?

Introduction

So you are considering buying a wheelchair but do not know which one to choose? When it comes wheelchairs, many people face the dilemma of choosing between a manual wheelchair or an electric one. The great thing about choosing is there is no wrong choice. Ultimately, it depends on numerous factors based on your specific needs and lifestyle. At First Holistic Life, we believe in empowering customers to make decisions by exploring the factors that can help make an informed decision.

Physical Capabilities and Needs

One of the primary factors when deciding between a manual or electric wheelchair is your physical capabilities and needs. Everyone has different abilities and needs, so having strong self awareness is important when deciding. A couple of areas to consider are the strength and dexterity of your upper body. If you possess good upper body strength and coordination, a manual wheelchair may be suitable for you. Manual wheelchairs require self-propulsion, which can provide exercise and maintain independence. This can be particularly beneficial from a mental health perspective due to the endorphins created from exercise. Conversely, if you have limited upper body strength or fatigue easily, an electric wheelchair might be a better option as it offers powered mobility, reducing strain and fatigue.

Lifestyle and Environment

Assessing your lifestyle and environment is crucial in determining which type of wheelchair suits you best. If you live in an urban area with even terrain and smooth surfaces, a manual wheelchair can provide maneuverability and ease of use. It allows you to navigate tight spaces and travel independently. On the other hand, if you reside in a rural area or encounter challenging terrains, an electric wheelchair's motorized features can assist you in traversing slopes, uneven surfaces, or longer distances with less effort. It's best to take into consideration your local terrain and where you expect to travel to in the future.

Portability and Transport

The portability and ease of transport are important when deciding between a manual or electric wheelchair. Manual wheelchairs are generally lightweight and compact, making them more convenient for frequent travel or transportation. They can be easily folded and stored in a car trunk or taken on public transportation. Electric wheelchairs, while offering enhanced mobility, tend to be heavier and bulkier. However, there are plenty of electric wheelchairs that fold and can be transported. This decision can also depends on whether you have significant help either from family or a medical institution to assist. Ensure that your living situation and transportation needs align with the wheelchair's weight, size, and compatibility with vehicle lifts or ramps.

Cost and Insurance

Financial considerations play a significant role in the decision-making process. Manual wheelchairs are typically more affordable upfront, as they lack the motorized components of electric wheelchairs. However, it is important to evaluate the long-term costs associated with manual wheelchair maintenance, repairs, and replacement of worn-out parts. Electric wheelchairs often come with a higher initial cost, but they may be covered by insurance plans or government assistance programs. Research your insurance coverage and consider your budget to make an informed choice.

Social and Emotional Factors

Social and emotional factors should not be overlooked when selecting a wheelchair. The stigma associated with mobility aids can impact an individual's self-image and confidence. While ensuring that your physical health is addressed, it is extremely important to consider one's mental health when it comes to choosing the best option for them. Some people may prefer the discreet nature of a manual wheelchair, as it can blend into social settings more seamlessly. Conversely, an electric wheelchair's advanced features might provide a sense of empowerment and increased participation in social activities. Reflect on your personal preferences and emotional well-being when deciding on a wheelchair type. It may also be helpful to talk to family members, medical professionals, or therapists to help you assess which option would be best for you.

Conclusion

Choosing between a manual or electric wheelchair is a personal decision that requires careful consideration. By evaluating your physical capabilities, lifestyle, portability needs, financial considerations, and emotional factors, you can make an informed choice that best supports your mobility and enhances your overall quality of life. Remember, consult with healthcare professionals and mobility experts to guide you through the decision-making process and ensure the wheelchair you choose meets your specific requirements. At the end of the day, it is YOUR decision and there is no one way to go about this. First Holistic Life provides multiple manual and electric wheelchair options to serve your needs.

If you still need help or have questions, please do not hesitate to contact hello@firstholisticlife.com.